The Plate Log Rule

Some food is good in the moment. A Star Plate stays with us long after the table has been cleared. To earn one, it must be something we would recommend without hesitation and happily order again tomorrow. No scores or checklists, just food we believe is worth seeking out.

Bora, deck 15 Rooftop gardens, speciality, $45

Lobster medallions

The lobster dish that won over two non-fans: tender medallions in a lemon beurre blanc worth mopping up.
The lobster dish that won over two non-fans: tender medallions in a lemon beurre blanc worth mopping up.

We’re not usually lobster fans, which made this one of the biggest surprises at Bora brunch. The lobster medallions were tender and sweet, but the lemon beurre blanc made the dish. Rich, buttery and lifted by just enough citrus, it was the kind of sauce that had us going back for every last drop. We would order it again for the sauce alone.

Bora, deck 15 Rooftop gardens, speciality, $45

French Toast

Celebrity Xcel Med — tableware, utensil, plate
The French toast we nearly skipped: thick-cut, golden and covered with Chantilly cream, caramelised pecans and maple syrup.

We had already chosen one dish from Bora’s brunch for our Star Plates list, so when our waiter insisted we stay for “a little dessert” and try the French toast, we expected it to be good. We did not expect another winner. The thick, golden toast arrived with butter, maple syrup, Chantilly cream and caramelised pecans. It was crisp at the edges, soft in the middle, and unapologetically rich, with the pecans adding just enough crunch. One of the best French toasts we’ve ever eaten, and proof that sometimes you should simply trust your waiter.

mosaic, deck 4, speciality, $95

Barolo-braised Iberico pork cheeks

Celebrity Xcel Med — tableware, utensil, plate
The recommendation we nearly missed: melt-in-the-mouth Iberico pork cheeks served over Parmesan risotto.

Once again, our waiter knew better than we did. We had not planned to order the pork cheeks, but his recommendation proved impossible to resist. The Barolo-braised meat was so tender it fell apart under the fork and melted in the mouth. Beneath it, the Parmesan risotto was creamy and packed with flavour, while the summer vegetables cut through the richness. A dish we might easily have missed became one of the best things we ate at Mosaic.

cosmopolitan, deck 4, main dining room, FREE

Strawberry angel food cake

Celebrity Xcel Med — tableware, utensil, plate
Soft strawberry angel food cake filled with whipped cream and fresh berries, finished with mango coulis.

After a full dinner at Cosmopolitan, this was exactly the kind of dessert we wanted. The strawberry angel food cake was soft and airy, filled with whipped cream and fresh strawberries, then finished with a bright mango coulis. It was fruity and light without feeling like the sensible option. Simple on paper, but far more memorable on the plate.

mosaic, deck 4, speciality, $95

Jumbo lump crab cake

Celebrity Xcel Med — tableware, utensil, plate
Fresh jumbo lump crab, minimal filler and a spicy chipotle aioli on the side.

This is how we want a crab cake to be: packed with fresh jumbo lump crab and barely enough filler to hold it together. You could taste the crab, not breadcrumbs. The crisp golden top added texture, while the creamy chipotle aioli brought a welcome kick. Piquillo pepper, cucumber and dill kept the whole thing fresh rather than heavy.

Magic carpet, deck 14, speciality, $129

Surf and turf at Dinner on the Edge

Celebrity Xcel Med — tableware, utensil, drinking glass
The best steak we ate on the cruise, paired with grilled lobster high above the sea on the Magic Carpet.

Dinner on the Edge takes over the Magic Carpet for one night of the cruise, so the setting already makes the evening feel special. Somehow, the food matched it. The pan-seared filet mignon was the best steak we ate on board, beautifully cooked and full of flavour, while the grilled lobster tail complemented it perfectly. Bordelaise and béarnaise sauces brought everything together, with mashed potato, asparagus and caviar making the plate as indulgent as the occasion.